Dec 03

Facebook recently launched a new service called Beacon which tracks, via participating partners, the purchases of it’s members. The partnership seems to be monetized by the posting of recent purchases to “friends” mini-feeds further driving traffic to affiliates. I don’t think very many people want what they are buying being the business of anyone, let alone being broadcast to all their friends without their permissions. Aside from the obvious problems, like spoiling a Christmas surprise present or a more intimate product purchase, this is just plain wrong. They launched the service quietly and made it OPT OUT, meaning you are part of it unless you tell them you don’t want to be. Opt out just isn’t how things are done anymore. We live in a double OPT IN world. You have to ask me if it’s okay and then confirm that I’m the one that said okay.

But this isn’t my only concern with Facebook and them keeping my data “private”. I recently did a Facebook application for a client and during the process I realized that I had access to just about everything in a users profile that visited the application. Most of it’s just fluff data, nothing personal like credit card info, social security number, email address, etc. But my real name is in there and, if I choose to, my political, religious and other affiliations. Someone could use that to target me in a number of ways that I’m not comfortable with. I haven’t seen an option to hide my data from 3rd part applications. I signed up to use Facebook and granted them and my friends access to this data. The odd thing here is that Facebook used to be a completely closed system and now the door has swung way back in the other direction and in my opinion, is playing it loose with their members privacy. I’m not easily spooked by privacy concerns but fir the first time since I’ve been online (1994!) I’m actually considering closing my account with a company due to how lose it is with my personal data.

Facebook could easily fix this by making Beacon opt in and making data captured by 3rd party developers optional in my profile as well. A simple check box for both would be both easy and make me feel pretty safe. I’m not sure I’d trust it to actually work at this point. I guess with rumors that the creator of Facebook stole the code from friends at college make this seem even more shady. Hopefully they’ll be able to solve all these concerns and make everyone happy. I know they need to make money but that’s never an excuse to violate your members privacy. Not ever.

Technorati Tags: ,

4 Responses to “Is Facebook Facing Privacy Problems?”

1 ses5909 Says:

I’m in agreement with you here. I’m not a big facebook user but I do have an account and what I buy is no’one’s business. I haven’t dabbled in facebook apps, but if what you are saying is true, you could create an app to allow someone to enter’s someone’s username and then see all of their info when they think it is only viewable by their friends.

2 Chrispian Says:

Yeah, I’m totally surprised by the level at which someone can get at your info. It’s not “easy”, but any developer could store you’re data if you install their app. I’d really like to see an option where I could choose who gets to see my data.

3 Jewels Pornakova Says:

I’m actually shocked I haven’t heard of more people finding holes in facebook to exploit. Note that Digg has had a lot of problems with people finding holes and abusing them to get front-paged or gain 100s of friends. But Facebook has a lot more private info that is sensitive.

4 AST Supplements Says:

Superb! Generally I never read whole articles but the way you wrote this information is simply fantastic and this kept my interest in reading and I enjoyed it. You have got brilliant writing skills.

Leave a Reply

By submitting a comment here you grant this site a perpetual license to reproduce your words and name/web site in attribution. I reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason with and will aggressively smite spam, flames and unsavory behavior.